TCM Reviews Logo

TCM Reviews

'TCM Reviews for Book, Ebook, and Audio Book Reviews in Every Genre'


Win a Book!
Current Contest

Painter Contest

Past Reviews For Authors For Reviewers For Adults Only TCM BookstoreContact Us

TCM Reviews Newsletter
Get weekly reviews and contest updates sent directly to your inbox.
Subscribe Now!

Google
Web
Past Reviews

Technicians of the Sacred
Jerome Rothenberg
University of California Press
ISBN: 0-520-04912-8
Non-Fiction, Literary, History
Reviewed by Dr. Tami Brady

Technicians of the Sacred was compiled by Rothenberg after attending two 1964 readings of “Primitive and Archaic Poetry” at The Poet’s Hardware Theater and the Café Metro in New York city. Intrigued with the deep intuition of these works, Rothenberg decided to collect poetry, songs, and chants from around the world.

Rothenberg’s intention was not to focus on any one particular aspect of the sacred but merely to compile material that was available in English and the book’s organization directly reflects this lack of apparent direction. Works are subdivided into nine sections: Origins & Namings; Visions & Spells; Death & Defeat; The Book of Events (I); The Book of Events (II); Africa; America; Asia; Europe & The Ancient Near East; and Oceana. Having material from the first five sections more or less focused around a specific theme while the remaining five sections reflect a geographic focus the work feeling a little thrown together and disorganized.

This disorganization is further reflected within each section, where there is everything from modern poetry and prose through traditional songs and chants to ancient pictographs and artwork. Moreover works from individual cultural groups are not placed together but dispersed throughout each section.

That the work only reflects English translations is also somewhat problematic. A Commentary section at the back of the book explains how Rothenberg came across each work offering explanations about the themes and topics within a particular piece. However, more often than not, these notes did not describe how the piece was translated. This lack of information would be particularly useful as Rothenberg states that the translations vary from literal to very free. This book does contain a number of interesting and useful pieces. Rothenberg has chosen a good mixture of poetry from a variety of different sources, not just the most accessible and he illustrates poems from the Paleolithic through to modern times. Moreover, this book contains some very interesting and intriguing transitional pieces reflecting Christian religious teaching modified into traditional forms. Thus, despite some very irritating and distracting organizational problems, this book contains some very valuable information. This information will likely be of use to those wishing to gain insight into aspects of the sacred in general or those wanting insight into the belief systems of particular cultures. Nonetheless, the apparent lack of organization of these pieces make this book an unlikely candidate as a classroom text.

HOME    REVIEW REQUEST     PROMOTIONAL PACKAGES     BE A REVIEWER     PAST REVIEWS     SITEMAP    CONTACT

Copyright©2005-2008 TCM, Dr. Tami Brady. All Rights Reserved.